Alle rapporten
Potion Explosion rapporten
#18760: "UNDO"
Waarover gaat dit rapport?
Wat is er gebeurd? Selecteer uit het onderstaande
Suggestie: volgens mij zou het volgende de implementatie van dit spel enorm verbeteren
Gedetailleerde beschrijving
⢠Gelieve jouw suggestie precies en beknopt uit te leggen zodat het zo makkelijk mogelijk is om te begrijpen wat je bedoelt.
Potion Explosion needs a serious undo button. I find myself not so much making wrong game decisions as much as making erroneous mouse clicks. The game is backwards with regard to how selections are made. For example I need to select a marble before selecting an action. Also, with regard to placement from one's hand it is impossible to undo your placements after selections are made. I also think that selection is backwards. One should choose their action then select a marble, not select a marble then choose what to do with it.
⢠Welke browser gebruik je?
Google Chrome v80
Rapportgeschiedenis
6 jun 2020 2:49 ⢠Lemminkainen ⢠De ontwikkelaars hebben deze suggestie nog niet geanalyseerd:
The Prismatic potion implementation is really bad as well. The marbles should just be automatically moved to a player's pool.
I am playing games with friends, but am making so many mouse-errors that it's ridiculous. I'd feel better if I was making strategy errors, but this seems very buggy the way people have to select and place marbles.
I am playing games with friends, but am making so many mouse-errors that it's ridiculous. I'd feel better if I was making strategy errors, but this seems very buggy the way people have to select and place marbles.
9 jun 2020 16:25 ⢠Mr_Magic ⢠De ontwikkelaars hebben deze suggestie nog niet geanalyseerd:
The prismatic implementation is fine.
With the prismatic potion only ingredients in yur pool can be used as wildcards. Ig you have 4 ingredients in your hand and an empty pool how doe the game know which one you want to keep for after? There may be a tactical decision over which yu use as wlds and which you use for their own colour later.
With the prismatic potion only ingredients in yur pool can be used as wildcards. Ig you have 4 ingredients in your hand and an empty pool how doe the game know which one you want to keep for after? There may be a tactical decision over which yu use as wlds and which you use for their own colour later.
15 jul 2020 17:57 ⢠tallfred ⢠De ontwikkelaars hebben deze suggestie nog niet geanalyseerd:
I didn't even click, the mouse was nowhere near the ingredient and yet the interface decided I wanted this random ingredient. I realise that the interface bug would be hard to find, but please incorporate the undo function soon.
18 jul 2020 7:34 ⢠MoonGoyal ⢠De ontwikkelaars hebben deze suggestie nog niet geanalyseerd:
I agree,
If an Undo button is not possible due to the nature of the game. Please make it so the "selection" button confirms if your only going to be taking 1 ingredient (not causing any explosions).
Because this is an all to common mistake, is clicking the wrong option at the top.
Table #102022060
Move #128
Progression 20%
If an Undo button is not possible due to the nature of the game. Please make it so the "selection" button confirms if your only going to be taking 1 ingredient (not causing any explosions).
Because this is an all to common mistake, is clicking the wrong option at the top.
Table #102022060
Move #128
Progression 20%
18 jul 2020 7:45 ⢠JeffreyEAnderson ⢠De ontwikkelaars hebben deze suggestie nog niet geanalyseerd:
It would be nice to have either an undo button or a message that asks if you are sure you want to make the move.
16 aug 2020 4:12 ⢠Charmed88 ⢠De ontwikkelaars hebben deze suggestie nog niet geanalyseerd:
Sometimes i fill the wrong potion by mistake and want it on my other potion but cant take from my potion back to my hand. undo would be great
8 sep 2020 15:21 ⢠Missandry ⢠De ontwikkelaars hebben deze suggestie nog niet geanalyseerd:
undo should definitely be available after getting 'help' (i.e. not causing any explosions) by mistake
23 sep 2020 9:21 ⢠metallicacello ⢠De ontwikkelaars hebben deze suggestie nog niet geanalyseerd:
I've seen several people have issues with the prismatic potion. If there's nothing in the pool and you select the potion, you're out of luck. Seems like a given that the next three you click would've been in the pool, or maybe you could be allowed to move them during the action?
6 okt 2020 13:52 ⢠dlisboa ⢠De ontwikkelaars hebben deze suggestie nog niet geanalyseerd:
Undo should be available for any action or actions sequence in winch the player has not gained knowledge they didn't previously had (as it is in The Voyages of Marco Polo). I.e. all actions that do not involve taking marbles from any slider because this shows witch marbles come next on that slider.
13 okt 2020 10:07 ⢠RicardoRix ⢠De ontwikkelaars hebben deze suggestie nog niet geanalyseerd:
'undo should definitely be available after getting 'help' (i.e. not causing any explosions) by mistake'
So many times I've picked the ingredient rather than what I meant was - 'get help'.
Not only have I wasted a whole turn, but I've completely setup my opponent for the perfect move.
I think an explosion move (pick ingredient) should definitely come with an undo if no subsequent explosion happens.
So many times I've picked the ingredient rather than what I meant was - 'get help'.
Not only have I wasted a whole turn, but I've completely setup my opponent for the perfect move.
I think an explosion move (pick ingredient) should definitely come with an undo if no subsequent explosion happens.
3 dec 2020 3:21 ⢠Lemminkainen ⢠De ontwikkelaars hebben deze suggestie nog niet geanalyseerd:
Thanks for the everyone's feedback. Hopefully the developers will get back to us on this.
I think the key thing is that the "touch then select action" implementation is backwards. If that can be fixed then the game would be magnitudes better. I think it should be "select action then touch marbles".....with a huge confirmation button of course.
I think the key thing is that the "touch then select action" implementation is backwards. If that can be fixed then the game would be magnitudes better. I think it should be "select action then touch marbles".....with a huge confirmation button of course.
31 dec 2020 8:41 ⢠Otithes ⢠De ontwikkelaars hebben deze suggestie nog niet geanalyseerd:
THE RULES DO NOT ALLOW FOR "UNDO" while brewing a potion. The rule book states clearly:
"First, you must place any Ingredients in your hand on the matching empty holes of the same color on any Potion tiles brewing on your Desk, if possible (a yellow marble goes on a yellow hole, etc.). Once an Ingredient has been placed on a Potion tile, it cannot be moved until the Potion is complete."
There is no "undo" for taking marbles from the track, either. Anyone who's ever seen the physical game knows that there is no way players would be able to accurately put back the marbles they caused to explode during their turn. An undo option for taking marbles makes no sense at all.
The game is properly implemented on BGA when it comes to the "undo" options.
"First, you must place any Ingredients in your hand on the matching empty holes of the same color on any Potion tiles brewing on your Desk, if possible (a yellow marble goes on a yellow hole, etc.). Once an Ingredient has been placed on a Potion tile, it cannot be moved until the Potion is complete."
There is no "undo" for taking marbles from the track, either. Anyone who's ever seen the physical game knows that there is no way players would be able to accurately put back the marbles they caused to explode during their turn. An undo option for taking marbles makes no sense at all.
The game is properly implemented on BGA when it comes to the "undo" options.
1 feb 2021 12:46 ⢠Clareybear ⢠De ontwikkelaars hebben deze suggestie nog niet geanalyseerd:
I'm less bothered about undo than just there must be a better way to implement the 'get help' function when it leads to countless misclicks...
27 dec 2021 5:22 ⢠panaggio ⢠De ontwikkelaars hebben deze suggestie nog niet geanalyseerd:
This is a must have. The game isn't broken without it, but I keep feeling I should stop until this is fixed, because it's so annoying. This is the kind of game where a silly click might be your demise. And it happened so much to me.
5 jan 2022 21:18 ⢠Lacalguy ⢠De ontwikkelaars hebben deze suggestie nog niet geanalyseerd:
Yes, I agree that an undo button would aid in playing the game. Sometimes, I want to put a single pebble in a flask and accidentally put all the pebbles possible in the flask. An undo button would resolve this issue.
8 jan 2022 6:37 ⢠Shaynanigans ⢠De ontwikkelaars hebben deze suggestie nog niet geanalyseerd:
I used my potion of prismatic joy but my marbles werenât in the pool, they were above so I wasted the potion. There needs to be an undo option because the order of this game gets so confusing. I get more red error messages on this game than any other and I never understand the messages, warnings or order I should do things in. As a new player to this game, it is very frustrating. Additionally, for the get help button it makes sense to me to select the button then select the marble, instead of giving me an error message and making me select an ingredient then the get help button. It is set up backwards to me.
This game needs an undo button and more tweaks.
This game needs an undo button and more tweaks.
3 jun 2022 18:03 ⢠tcavalet ⢠De ontwikkelaars hebben deze suggestie nog niet geanalyseerd:
Please add this, really annoying at the moment. And example would be clikcing on the Potion of Prismatic Joy without first moving pebles from my hand to the pool, urgh. Please add undo.
24 jul 2022 20:31 ⢠Baron Frog ⢠De ontwikkelaars hebben deze suggestie nog niet geanalyseerd:
Yes, this would be a great addition to the game. If the rulebook says you can't do it, then make it an option for players to choose whether to allow an Undo, which is exactly what you'd do if playing this in real life.
As it is the interface is so woeful that it is far too easy not to do what would be simple in a real life game.
As it is the interface is so woeful that it is far too easy not to do what would be simple in a real life game.
1 aug 2022 23:40 ⢠RebelMike ⢠De ontwikkelaars hebben deze suggestie nog niet geanalyseerd:
I appreciate that anything that adds marbles to the dispenser can't be undone, but in other cases it would be very nice to offer an undo. Just now I hit fill thinking it would fill the red layer of my potion with 4 green marbles (with the expansion), and instead it put one red marble into the layer - an undo would have sorted that out rather than leaving me rather frustrated. As I was the one to find the bug where potions effect the wrong dispenser, breaking one of my previous turns in the same game, I ended up having a very bad experience of the game!
28 sep 2022 14:33 ⢠MCSirCH ⢠De ontwikkelaars hebben deze suggestie nog niet geanalyseerd:
I could have used undo today, I mistakenly pressed "take marble" instead of "get help" and hence I only picked up a total of 2 marbles when I should have gotten around 6.
12 okt 2022 20:05 ⢠Emerald13 ⢠De ontwikkelaars hebben deze suggestie nog niet geanalyseerd:
Not being able to remove an ingredient from a potion is both thematic and explicitly part of the rules, so an undo button is not possible. A confirmation step would be a better implementation.
28 dec 2022 0:57 ⢠majdi7 ⢠De ontwikkelaars hebben deze suggestie nog niet geanalyseerd:
I finished my turn but kept getting an error that I must play all my ingredients. I played the yellow to satisfy the error. But I am getting the error again. I'm assuming it wants the green marble but then the game is forcing me into a -1 scolding when I could just as easily put the green marble in the yellow space. I think this qualifies for an undo button as I'm not finished my turn. If the undo button is to be argued, the error message of "matching" ingredient is a mislead because it directs a user to use the yellow on yellow, not the green. 2 words "or wild" would provide clarity. I know the base game doesn't include wild so careful word choice is needed. This is screwing up the game and it's BGA related due to tool tip message error, and not actual game related.
I included a screen shot for reference
i.imgur.com/bcEyr8B.jpg
I included a screen shot for reference
i.imgur.com/bcEyr8B.jpg
31 dec 2022 0:03 ⢠KongKing123 ⢠De ontwikkelaars hebben deze suggestie nog niet geanalyseerd:
@majdi7: this should be filed as a separate bug (or perhaps there is a similar report already).
25 jan 2023 21:55 ⢠bonnyaclyde ⢠De ontwikkelaars hebben deze suggestie nog niet geanalyseerd:
I had a hand full of green enough to fill my potion so I clicked the auto fill button. 3 bad things happened. I got a scolding because the layers were filled in the wrong order. 1 blue was placed instead of 4 green and all my green were stolen by the next player because I was unable to place them. All because there was no confirm OR undo for the auto fill.
Also all my fellow players have had at least one potion fail to work properly which has caused frustration and could have been cured by an undo button.
Also all my fellow players have had at least one potion fail to work properly which has caused frustration and could have been cured by an undo button.
25 mei 2023 0:36 ⢠nik592 ⢠De ontwikkelaars hebben deze suggestie nog niet geanalyseerd:
I agree that an undo button within the context of your turn should be doable. If playing the physical game, I don't think anyone would begrudge a user moving a marble just placed from one potion to another - so long as it was just placed on that turn. Once your turn is complete, marbles should obviously not be able to be moved, but you should basically be able to reset your turn and start over. Many games have this implemented, and I'm sure their rules also include "once you place x, you can't move it".
I'd also agree a warning where you take a marble without causing any explosions would be nice, as I've clicked the wrong button on occasion. Again, in real life, you would just say, oh, that was my help for the turn, and then take your proper turn - I don't think you have to declare before you remove a marble whether it's help or your turn proper.
I'd also agree a warning where you take a marble without causing any explosions would be nice, as I've clicked the wrong button on occasion. Again, in real life, you would just say, oh, that was my help for the turn, and then take your proper turn - I don't think you have to declare before you remove a marble whether it's help or your turn proper.
18 feb 2024 10:39 ⢠KongKing123 ⢠De ontwikkelaars hebben deze suggestie nog niet geanalyseerd:
Bump to avoid automatic closure.
15 jun 2024 22:44 ⢠matagouri ⢠De ontwikkelaars hebben deze suggestie nog niet geanalyseerd:
Agreed on really needing an undo/confirm option for placing the current hand of marbles into potions, just like we can pull them back from the storage flask. It may require bookkeeping whether a given marble was placed this turn vs. previously, but it's well worth it.
28 jan 2025 1:13 ⢠psyven ⢠De ontwikkelaars hebben deze suggestie nog niet geanalyseerd:
Yeah, highly recommend being able to undo whenever new information from the marble dispenser isn't revealed. Prismatic Joy, Blind Love, or just placing any marble into a potion.
8 apr 2025 21:37 ⢠melware94 ⢠De ontwikkelaars hebben deze suggestie nog niet geanalyseerd:
Bump, this is urgent, kills my motivation to play
Dit rapport aanvullen
Gelieve hier alle informatie toe te voegen die relevant is om deze bug te reproduceren of jouw suggestie te begrijpen:
- Andere tafel ID / zet ID
- Loste F5 het probleem op?
- Kwam het probleem meerdere keren voor? Altijd? Willekeurig?
- Als je een schermafbeelding van deze bug hebt (goede gewoonte), kun je Imgur.com gebruiken om deze te uploaden, de link kopiĂŤren en hier plakken.
