#75834: "Game declared us winners when we got executed by queen"
Waarover gaat dit rapport?
Wat is er gebeurd? Selecteer uit het onderstaande
Wat is er gebeurd? Selecteer uit het onderstaande
Gelieve na te kijken of er reeds een rapport bestaat met hetzelfde onderwerp
Zo ja, gelieve dan voor dit rapport te STEMMEN. Rapporten met de meeste stemmen krijgen VOORRANG!
| # | Status | Votes | Game | Type | Title | Last update |
|---|
Gedetailleerde beschrijving
• Kopieer en plak alsjeblieft de foutboodschap die je op je scherm ziet, indien van toepassing.
The logs says that we got executed by the queen, but the game end screen says we are both winners. I don't know if this was intended since that was my first game.
The garden was not fully filled either.• Leg uit wat je wilde doen, wat je deed en wat er gebeurde
• Welke browser gebruik je?
Google Chrome v107
• Kopieer en plak alsjeblieft de tekst die in het Engels wordt getoond in plaats van in jouw taal. Als je een schermafbeelding van deze bug hebt (goede gewoonte), kun je Imgur.com gebruiken om deze te uploaden, de link kopiëren en hier plakken.
The logs says that we got executed by the queen, but the game end screen says we are both winners. I don't know if this was intended since that was my first game.
The garden was not fully filled either.• Is deze tekst beschikbaar in het vertaalsysteem? Zo ja, is deze meer dan 24 uur geleden vertaald?
• Welke browser gebruik je?
Google Chrome v107
• Gelieve jouw suggestie precies en beknopt uit te leggen zodat het zo makkelijk mogelijk is om te begrijpen wat je bedoelt.
The logs says that we got executed by the queen, but the game end screen says we are both winners. I don't know if this was intended since that was my first game.
The garden was not fully filled either.• Welke browser gebruik je?
Google Chrome v107
• Wat stond op het scherm toen je geblokkeerd was (Leeg scherm? Een deel van de spelinterface? Foutboodschap?)
The logs says that we got executed by the queen, but the game end screen says we are both winners. I don't know if this was intended since that was my first game.
The garden was not fully filled either.• Welke browser gebruik je?
Google Chrome v107
• Met welk onderdeel van de regels is geen rekening gehouden bij de BGA-versie?
The logs says that we got executed by the queen, but the game end screen says we are both winners. I don't know if this was intended since that was my first game.
The garden was not fully filled either.• Is de inbreuk op de spelregels zichtbaar in de spelherhaling? Indien ja, bij welk zetnummer?
• Welke browser gebruik je?
Google Chrome v107
• Welke spelactie wilde je uitvoeren?
The logs says that we got executed by the queen, but the game end screen says we are both winners. I don't know if this was intended since that was my first game.
The garden was not fully filled either.• Wat probeerde je te doen om deze spelactie te laten optreden?
• Wat gebeurde er toen je dit probeerde te doen (foutboodschap, melding op de statusbalk van het spel, ...)?
• Welke browser gebruik je?
Google Chrome v107
• In welke fase van het spel deed het probleem zich voor (wat was de huidige spelinstructie)?
The logs says that we got executed by the queen, but the game end screen says we are both winners. I don't know if this was intended since that was my first game.
The garden was not fully filled either.• Wat gebeurde toen je deze spelactie probeerde (foutboodschap, melding op de statusbalk van het spel, ...)?
• Welke browser gebruik je?
Google Chrome v107
• Beschrijf alsjeblieft het probleem met de beeldweergave. Als je een schermafbeelding van deze bug hebt (goede gewoonte), kun je Imgur.com gebruiken om deze te uploaden, de link kopiëren en hier plakken.
The logs says that we got executed by the queen, but the game end screen says we are both winners. I don't know if this was intended since that was my first game.
The garden was not fully filled either.• Welke browser gebruik je?
Google Chrome v107
• Kopieer en plak alsjeblieft de tekst die in het Engels wordt getoond in plaats van in jouw taal. Als je een schermafbeelding van deze bug hebt (goede gewoonte), kun je Imgur.com gebruiken om deze te uploaden, de link kopiëren en hier plakken.
The logs says that we got executed by the queen, but the game end screen says we are both winners. I don't know if this was intended since that was my first game.
The garden was not fully filled either.• Is deze tekst beschikbaar in het vertaalsysteem? Zo ja, is deze meer dan 24 uur geleden vertaald?
• Welke browser gebruik je?
Google Chrome v107
• Gelieve jouw suggestie precies en beknopt uit te leggen zodat het zo makkelijk mogelijk is om te begrijpen wat je bedoelt.
The logs says that we got executed by the queen, but the game end screen says we are both winners. I don't know if this was intended since that was my first game.
The garden was not fully filled either.• Welke browser gebruik je?
Google Chrome v107
Rapportgeschiedenis
BGA treats any solo/co-op games with positive score as 'victory' (regardless of the game rules).
Although it is indeed mentioned that you can keep history track of your scores in the Royal Log as you mention, the Game End is very clear about the win conditions:
You and your teammates win if the royal garden is filled without the Gardeners being caught by the Queen.
Note: Players must still complete all phases of a turn, including guessing a Whim and moving the Queen, even on the turn the garden is fully filled.
You and your teammates immediately lose the game if the Queen reaches or passes the Gardeners on the score track
So it is really very much against the intent and nature of the game to declare a positive score as winning.
The final score will actually always be positive, it doesn’t mean anything but IRL is just kept for history in that Royal Log book.
Also, The final score can be 0 or negative if players end up with 10 points or less.
And the game stat doesn’t really reflect the intent of the game win condition.
Of course it is a co-op game, so ELO etc doesn’t count anyway, but it will still be really confusing and unsatisfying to see “win” declared when actually loosing through execution.
I would at least suggest to reopen the bug so other people can upvote it, so you can see how much feedback you get on it.
Unless the rules change I'll leave this ticket closed.
I am not suggesting a house rule, the actual rules from the game are very explicit:
“ You and your teammates immediately lose the game if the Queen reaches or passes the Gardeners on the score track “
It is actually your implementation and the default BGA behavior that are leading to a house rule, by incorrectly recording a positive score as a Win. (Other games on BGA sometimes work around this by forcing scores to become negative in case of specific losing conditions - something you could also easily achieve by for instance distracting another -1000 or whatever when executed by the queen)
Please, take this up again and discuss this issue with the publisher, it seems really strange that they would prefer to have all games declared as Win.
Dit rapport aanvullen
- Andere tafel ID / zet ID
- Loste F5 het probleem op?
- Kwam het probleem meerdere keren voor? Altijd? Willekeurig?
- Als je een schermafbeelding van deze bug hebt (goede gewoonte), kun je Imgur.com gebruiken om deze te uploaden, de link kopiëren en hier plakken.
