Alle rapporten
Eufraat & Tigris rapporten
#65567: "Civilization building placed in corner instead of straight line"
implemented: Deze suggestie werd uitgevoerd
2
Waarover gaat dit rapport?
Wat is er gebeurd? Selecteer uit het onderstaande
Suggestie: volgens mij zou het volgende de implementatie van dit spel enorm verbeteren
Gedetailleerde beschrijving
• Gelieve jouw suggestie precies en beknopt uit te leggen zodat het zo makkelijk mogelijk is om te begrijpen wat je bedoelt.
A civilization building should be triggered by 3 in a row horizontally or vertically, not 3 in a corner configuration, as far as I understand.
I completed 3 in a corner and the game offered me a civilization building for blue.• Welke browser gebruik je?
Mozilla v5
Rapportgeschiedenis
4 jun 2022 20:38 • GTSchemer • Bug is nog niet gereproduceerd door de ontwikkelaars:
Update: It happened at move #125. Not only did it let me place a civilization building on a blue L (not 3 in a row), but it also let me steal the civilization building from its current location (which was already on a row of 3).
As I understand the rules, you need a straight row or column of at least 4 to steal the building from a row/column of 3.
Situation before:
cdn.discordapp.com/attachments/982054987423170660/982714609599381514/unknown.png
Situation after:
cdn.discordapp.com/attachments/982054987423170660/982714935219994784/unknown.png
As I understand the rules, you need a straight row or column of at least 4 to steal the building from a row/column of 3.
Situation before:
cdn.discordapp.com/attachments/982054987423170660/982714609599381514/unknown.png
Situation after:
cdn.discordapp.com/attachments/982054987423170660/982714935219994784/unknown.png
4 jun 2022 20:42 • CoconutTank • Bug is nog niet gereproduceerd door de ontwikkelaars:
6 jun 2022 17:38 • thenmal • Bug is bevestigd door de ontwikkelaars:
Thanks for the report, this is a problem. Will fix in an upcoming update.
7 jun 2022 22:41 • thenmal • De ontwikkelaars vragen meer informatie om deze bug te reproduceren:
This took some digging, but this appears to actually be a display bug.
During the war on move 70, the line of blue tiles the adv civ building was connected to were destroyed, leaving it sitting alone on a line of length 1. Later on turn 115 when a blue tile was placed making a line of 2 (horizontally), the building was moved.
pre-war: i.notabigtruck.com/i/wLVCn.png
post-war: i.notabigtruck.com/i/AMivH.png
building move: i.notabigtruck.com/i/BrdMb.png
The line is only required to be of length 3 if the building is being placed on the board. It need only be longer if it is moving.
Were your screenshots taken using the "fast replay" option, or during gameplay?
During the war on move 70, the line of blue tiles the adv civ building was connected to were destroyed, leaving it sitting alone on a line of length 1. Later on turn 115 when a blue tile was placed making a line of 2 (horizontally), the building was moved.
pre-war: i.notabigtruck.com/i/wLVCn.png
post-war: i.notabigtruck.com/i/AMivH.png
building move: i.notabigtruck.com/i/BrdMb.png
The line is only required to be of length 3 if the building is being placed on the board. It need only be longer if it is moving.
Were your screenshots taken using the "fast replay" option, or during gameplay?
8 jun 2022 20:48 • GTSchemer • De ontwikkelaars vragen meer informatie om deze bug te reproduceren:
I took the screenshots during replay, but I thought I saw the same thing during the game.
I do see your point that stealing a monument from a line of 1 or 2 should be legal. Your screenshots look more correct, and I understand that the blue tiles got deleted due to war but the monument remained alone.
I do see your point that stealing a monument from a line of 1 or 2 should be legal. Your screenshots look more correct, and I understand that the blue tiles got deleted due to war but the monument remained alone.
8 jun 2022 22:58 • GTSchemer • De ontwikkelaars vragen meer informatie om deze bug te reproduceren:
@thenmal it is definitely still bugged. From a live game:
cdn.discordapp.com/attachments/982054987423170660/984199416061780008/unknown.png
Without any wars involved, I was allowed to place the civilization building with a column of 2. For some reason I also could not undo, afterwards.
cdn.discordapp.com/attachments/982054987423170660/984199416061780008/unknown.png
Without any wars involved, I was allowed to place the civilization building with a column of 2. For some reason I also could not undo, afterwards.
8 jun 2022 23:06 • GTSchemer • De ontwikkelaars vragen meer informatie om deze bug te reproduceren:
I'm so sorry, you are right, this was legitimate again because building WAS on the board but then the original line became small, and then the civilization building was stolen legitimately.
8 jun 2022 23:09 • thenmal • De ontwikkelaars hebben deze suggestie nog niet geanalyseerd:
Just had a chat in-game, this was working properly but the log message could be clearer.
I am going to clarify the log message for when a civ building is moved rather than placed.
I am going to clarify the log message for when a civ building is moved rather than placed.
8 jun 2022 23:09 • thenmal • De ontwikkelaars zijn het eens dat dit een goed idee is en zijn van plan hieraan te werken:
Reclassified as suggestion, see above.
8 jun 2022 23:19 • thenmal • De ontwikkelaars zijn het eens dat dit een goed idee is en zijn van plan hieraan te werken:
After further conversation and reading some old BGG threads.
boardgamegeek.com/thread/1421421/article/20107063#20107063
I am going to change the implementation to needing 3 tiles AND greater to move a building.
boardgamegeek.com/thread/1421421/article/20107063#20107063
I am going to change the implementation to needing 3 tiles AND greater to move a building.
Dit rapport aanvullen
Gelieve hier alle informatie toe te voegen die relevant is om deze bug te reproduceren of jouw suggestie te begrijpen:
- Andere tafel ID / zet ID
- Loste F5 het probleem op?
- Kwam het probleem meerdere keren voor? Altijd? Willekeurig?
- Als je een schermafbeelding van deze bug hebt (goede gewoonte), kun je Imgur.com gebruiken om deze te uploaden, de link kopiëren en hier plakken.
