Rapport • Board Game Arena

Alle rapporten

Homeworlds rapporten

#54265: "UX appraoch is confusing"

implemented: Deze suggestie werd uitgevoerd

Waarover gaat dit rapport?

Homeworlds #220757521

Wat is er gebeurd? Selecteer uit het onderstaande

Suggestie: volgens mij zou het volgende de implementatie van dit spel enorm verbeteren

Wat is er gebeurd? Selecteer uit het onderstaande

Suggestie: volgens mij zou het volgende de implementatie van dit spel enorm verbeteren

Controleer of er al een rapport is over hetzelfde onderwerp

Zo ja, gelieve dan voor dit rapport te STEMMEN. Rapporten met de meeste stemmen krijgen VOORRANG!

#	Status	Votes	Game	Type	Title	Last update

Gedetailleerde beschrijving

Rapportgeschiedenis

2 Dec 2021 20:12 • mneme • De ontwikkelaars hebben deze suggestie nog niet geanalyseerd:

The usual BGA UX is either "select action, then select how to do it" would work. But since homeworlds is piece-first I think it would be reasonable to reverse it -- select a piece and then get a menu of actions you can do (divorce it from WHY you can do only those actions; that's not important right now and people can read the rulebook), putting Sacrifice LAST.

However, the current module is basically the worst:

New players don't get a menu of what they can do, so it's really easy for them to miss options or just select the wrong one.

Existing players can't just select the action the ywant; they have to make the non-decision of deciding -how- to do it and choosing between the ship itself and oher ships/systems when it doesn't matter.

For experienced players it would also be nice to be able to initiate a grow/swap by clicking on a piece in the stash first (and then get prrompted for whether you want to grow that piece or trade for it if both options are on the table, and then click on the system you want to grow in or the ship you want to swap it for), and initiate an attack by clicking on the enemy you want to attack. But obviously that wouldn't help novice players much while a clearer flow really would.

5 Dec 2021 23:39 • Babamots • De ontwikkelaars zijn het eens dat dit een goed idee is en zijn van plan hieraan te werken:

I haven't started working on this yet, but I'm strongly considering changing the click order to "power" followed by "activated ship." When I get to this, I expect, the instructions to read something like these:
"You may choose a ship or star to use its power."
"You may choose a ship in the same system to activate it with ${color} power."

6 Dec 2021 10:05 • mneme • De ontwikkelaars zijn het eens dat dit een goed idee is en zijn van plan hieraan te werken:

That makes sense. I don't have a strong horse in power-first vs ship-first (obviously I'm used to power-first from SDG, but it's not a huge deal).

One nice thing about power-first would be that the UI could limit your choices rather than force a ship selection -- you'd select "Grow" and it would then show you which ships you could grow across your empire (without a sacrifice). Or you'd choose "sacrifice" and could then sacrifice any ship.

I haven't tried; does the system warn you if you're trying to end your side (like by sacrificing your only ship)?

6 Dec 2021 18:53 • Babamots • De ontwikkelaars zijn het eens dat dit een goed idee is en zijn van plan hieraan te werken:

There is a warning after you click "End turn" if you would be eliminated.

I haven't understood your suggestion very well, but I was proposing "power first" as a solution. In particular, I apparently haven't at all grasped what you meant by

"they have to make the non-decision of deciding -how- to do it and choosing between the ship itself and oher ships/systems when it doesn't matter."

Can you clarify?

It sounds like you might be saying you want more buttons with text on them (like a "grow" button). I want to avoid text-based interface elements where possible because clicking pieces is both cleaner and easier to write. The presence or absence of a color in a system automatically limits what kind of action a player can take, which I expect to be instructive for new players.

6 Dec 2021 21:04 • Babamots • De ontwikkelaars willen graag meer informatie over deze suggestie:

I think I just figured out out. Are you concerned about, when there are multiple pieces of the same cookie, player have to choose which of the same-colored pieces to click when choosing a power?

7 Dec 2021 06:18 • mneme • De ontwikkelaars willen graag meer informatie over deze suggestie:

Yeah. It underlies the mechanics, yes -- but it's a non-decision and because it adds extra non-decision mechanics it seems to make it harder for players to properly compass the decision space they actually have.

7 Dec 2021 07:40 • Babamots • De ontwikkelaars zijn het eens dat dit een goed idee is en zijn van plan hieraan te werken:

That's a good point. I'll contemplate ways to address this, preferably without scrapping the current interface entirely.

9 Dec 2021 00:08 • JustinInOhio • De ontwikkelaars zijn het eens dat dit een goed idee is en zijn van plan hieraan te werken:

New player here. I had no idea clicking the ship a second time to take the ship action was available/the correct thing to do. I spent 3 turns just changing ship colors before sacrificing and ending the game. Is clicking the ship a second a mandatory thing or could you just activate the area that the ship action would allow?

18 Dec 2021 13:50 • z_watcher • De ontwikkelaars zijn het eens dat dit een goed idee is en zijn van plan hieraan te werken:

If you go with using power first (you still get the sacrifice option top):
* When using red power, you could infer you are using your biggest ship in system to do it, meaning you could directly go to take any possible ship in the system
* When using green power, you could also directly highlight in the bank the options, depending on ship colors in the system

29 Jan 2022 14:37 • Jellby • De ontwikkelaars zijn het eens dat dit een goed idee is en zijn van plan hieraan te werken:

I'd suggest one of the following (A or B)

A)
1. Select action: Build, Change, Move, Capture, Sacrifice
2. Select ship. Ships that can perform the action are highlighted (or other ships are greyed out). In the capture case, you'd directly select an enemy ship.

B)
1. Select own ship.
2. Select action: Build, Change, Move, Capture, Sacrifice. Actions that this ship cannot perform because the color is not available in the system are greyed out.

28 May 2022 01:34 • Babamots • De ontwikkelaars zijn het eens dat dit een goed idee is en zijn van plan hieraan te werken:

I am still thinking about this, but I've taken care of some easier things first. The current plan is like Jellby's B suggestion: I'm going to keep the option to select pieces, but there will also be action buttons at the top that will be greyed out if the corresponding technology isn't available for the selected ship.

It will probably take a while to get this done because of life things, but I'll get there!

5 Jun 2022 00:46 • Babamots • Deze suggestie werd uitgevoerd:

I added buttons that appear during the power selection phase. The buttons are an unambiguous think to select for the power you want, and they help to guide players through the ship-power-target process.

Dit rapport aanvullen

Gelieve hier alle informatie toe te voegen die relevant is om deze bug te reproduceren of jouw suggestie te begrijpen:

Andere tafel ID / zet ID
Loste F5 het probleem op?
Kwam het probleem meerdere keren voor? Altijd? Willekeurig?
Als je een screenshot van de bug hebt (goede gewoonte), kun je een afbeeldingswebsite gebruiken (bijvoorbeeld snipboard.io) om deze te uploaden en de link hier te delen.

Annuleer Werk rapport bij

#54265: "UX appraoch is confusing"

Waarover gaat dit rapport?

Wat is er gebeurd? Selecteer uit het onderstaande

Wat is er gebeurd? Selecteer uit het onderstaande

Controleer of er al een rapport is over hetzelfde onderwerp

Gedetailleerde beschrijving

Rapportgeschiedenis

Dit rapport aanvullen

Wijzig rapportstatus naar:

Help

Draag bij

Navigeren

Volg ons