Rapport • Board Game Arena

Alle rapporten

Tichu (Tai Pan) rapporten

#31597: "Solve issues with timing of calling TIchu while passing"

acknowledged: De ontwikkelaars zijn het eens dat dit een goed idee is en zijn van plan hieraan te werken

Waarover gaat dit rapport?

Tichu (Tai Pan) #137795716

Wat is er gebeurd? Selecteer uit het onderstaande

Suggestie: volgens mij zou het volgende de implementatie van dit spel enorm verbeteren

Wat is er gebeurd? Selecteer uit het onderstaande

Suggestie: volgens mij zou het volgende de implementatie van dit spel enorm verbeteren

Controleer of er al een rapport is over hetzelfde onderwerp

Zo ja, gelieve dan voor dit rapport te STEMMEN. Rapporten met de meeste stemmen krijgen VOORRANG!

#	Status	Votes	Game	Type	Title	Last update

Gedetailleerde beschrijving

Rapportgeschiedenis

10 Jan 2021 02:06 • Cloudy • De ontwikkelaars hebben deze suggestie nog niet geanalyseerd:

Normally, face to face, if you have played your pass face down in front of you and not passed them yet you can respond to a Tichu by picking the cards up and changing your pass.

Since this can't be one on BGA then you shouldn't hit the confirm button quickly so that you can respond to a Tichu. It would be better to allow players to redo their pass if someone calls Tichu during the pass.

If my partner calls Grand Tichu my pass may be very different than if they didn't and I need someway to change pass.

11 Jan 2021 05:10 • yodajacobs • De ontwikkelaars hebben deze suggestie nog niet geanalyseerd:

The aspect of promoting slow play can be solved by making a Tichu call made before everyone confirms passes to have the side effect of resetting the pass confirmation state of anyone who already had confirmed what they were passing. That gives them the option to review their pass in light of the new information that someone has called Tichu. That way you can go ahead an set your pass, knowing that if someone calls Tichu you get a chance to change the pass, so there would be no reason to delay an initial pass confirmation just to wait to see if anyone was going to call.

23 Mar 2021 14:56 • RobRun • De ontwikkelaars hebben deze suggestie nog niet geanalyseerd:

I agree with yodajacobs - if people have passed cards and then someone calls Tichu, the pass should reset so you can change if necessary.

6 Apr 2021 12:20 • dexdouglas • De ontwikkelaars hebben deze suggestie nog niet geanalyseerd:

I also agree with YodaJacobs. In an asynch game, if I’m the last to decline Grand Tichu and I’m the first to select cards to pass, my partner might have wanted to call Tichu once they received their new cards but since my pass was already locked in, there’s nothing they can do.
I would add a button that says, “Call Tichu and reset pass.”

11 Apr 2021 01:10 • hakha3 • De ontwikkelaars hebben deze suggestie nog niet geanalyseerd:

agree with above that letting people to change their passes if someone during that time called tichu would be really cool. Additionally, with that change we could add that you can start exchanging cards once you decided to or not to call grand tichu without need to wait for others to call it. But I dont mind much just waiting for others grand tichu

24 May 2021 19:54 • jnads • De ontwikkelaars hebben deze suggestie nog niet geanalyseerd:

> Additionally, with that change we could add that you can start exchanging cards once you decided to or not to call grand tichu without need to wait for others to call it. But I dont mind much just waiting for others grand tichu

I think grand has to stay separate just because it means you have to start dealing out the deck.

But I do agree that anytime someone calls Tichu during passing it should just reset the entire passing state with a new refreshed game timer.

If two people call it, it resets twice.

24 Dec 2021 17:27 • theChony • De ontwikkelaars hebben deze suggestie nog niet geanalyseerd:

I agree that calling Tichu while passing cards should reset the choices for everyone. Please implement this change.

6 Jan 2022 07:04 • youngathearttx • De ontwikkelaars hebben deze suggestie nog niet geanalyseerd:

This seems like a "can of worms" to me. To be fair, wouldn't you have to allow the opponents to change their passes as well? That is going to mess with everyone's hands and strategy . I think it is just a "Quirk" of playing Asynch. I believe passing and calling Tichu is as fair as they can be in Asynch as is it is currently designed. Note: My asynch games last days, weeks, and months. It is great, and I love it. I agree that it is a slightly "different version" of TICHU than playing live. We are lucky enough to have the option to play asynch, live, or both!!! I vote NO on resetting.passes.

7 Aug 2023 19:56 • dashwood314 • De ontwikkelaars hebben deze suggestie nog niet geanalyseerd:

This is likely getting fixed with a new release next week, see this announcement for details: boardgamearena.com/forum/viewtopic.php?t=31862

8 Aug 2023 13:07 • deejinlondon • De ontwikkelaars hebben deze suggestie nog niet geanalyseerd:

I agree with Robrun and Yodajacobs

14 Aug 2023 10:43 • dashwood314 • De ontwikkelaars zijn het eens dat dit een goed idee is en zijn van plan hieraan te werken:

Sorry for my previous message. I had misunderstood this issue. We are clearly showing the Tichu calls in the pass cards panel, now. So this is done.

But what you are discussing here is about Tichu calls after one player has already passed.

I think it will be fairly hard to implement that all card passing is reset when someone calls Tichu. I agree that this would be the best solution, but you may have to wait forever until this gets implemented, because it takes a substantial amount of time.

Alternatively I could offer the second best option of just not allowing Tichu calls is at least one player (at not all players) have passed their cards. WDYT?

14 Aug 2023 17:51 • EpicDim • De ontwikkelaars zijn het eens dat dit een goed idee is en zijn van plan hieraan te werken:

That would be a good work around. Either wait until it's announced until everyone has passed or not allow it. With turn based, not allowing it could mean that you would not be able to call before the first trick is led.

14 Aug 2023 18:40 • yodajacobs • De ontwikkelaars zijn het eens dat dit een goed idee is en zijn van plan hieraan te werken:

I'm not sure that workaround adds anything. The initial complaint is about the current situation promoting slow play. As EpicDim indicates, the workaround would create a situation with turn-based where you wanted to call Tichu prior to the first lead but wouldn't have the chance because someone else leads the first trick while you don't have the table open ready to pounce. Your only way to avoid that would be to wait so that you were the last person to set their pass. Still promotes slow play, albeit maybe in a smaller number of cases. (Having two people who were of such a mind likely is a vanishingly small circumstance but would lead to deadlock as both waited to be last.)

Even if the workaround is added, I suggest keeping this bug open for the harder fix.

15 Aug 2023 02:12 • ufm • De ontwikkelaars zijn het eens dat dit een goed idee is en zijn van plan hieraan te werken:

How about adding Tichu call steps just before exchanging cards and just after exchanging cards (but before the first trick lead), like Grand Tichu call steps?

15 Aug 2023 02:16 • ufm • De ontwikkelaars zijn het eens dat dit een goed idee is en zijn van plan hieraan te werken:

With this solution all players are assured to have equal chances to declare Tichu before and after exchange.
Also, if this gets implemented, declaring Tichu DURING exchange should be blocked as it becomes redundant and promotes slow play as other comments say.

18 Aug 2023 21:43 • RobRun • De ontwikkelaars zijn het eens dat dit een goed idee is en zijn van plan hieraan te werken:

I would be in favour of this solution, although I recognise that there is also something to be said for the status quo.

Dit rapport aanvullen

Gelieve hier alle informatie toe te voegen die relevant is om deze bug te reproduceren of jouw suggestie te begrijpen:

Andere tafel ID / zet ID
Loste F5 het probleem op?
Kwam het probleem meerdere keren voor? Altijd? Willekeurig?
Als je een screenshot van de bug hebt (goede gewoonte), kun je een afbeeldingswebsite gebruiken (bijvoorbeeld snipboard.io) om deze te uploaden en de link hier te delen.

Annuleer Werk rapport bij

#31597: "Solve issues with timing of calling TIchu while passing"

Waarover gaat dit rapport?

Wat is er gebeurd? Selecteer uit het onderstaande

Wat is er gebeurd? Selecteer uit het onderstaande

Controleer of er al een rapport is over hetzelfde onderwerp

Gedetailleerde beschrijving

Rapportgeschiedenis

Dit rapport aanvullen

Wijzig rapportstatus naar:

Help

Draag bij

Navigeren

Volg ons