Rapport • Board Game Arena

Alle rapporten

Maracaibo rapporten

#116449: "Add additional confirmation before delivering"

rejected: De ontwikkelaars denken dat dit geen goed idee is of dat de kosten/batenratio te hoog is

Waarover gaat dit rapport?

Maracaibo #470376790

Wat is er gebeurd? Selecteer uit het onderstaande

Suggestie: volgens mij zou het volgende de implementatie van dit spel enorm verbeteren

Wat is er gebeurd? Selecteer uit het onderstaande

Suggestie: volgens mij zou het volgende de implementatie van dit spel enorm verbeteren

Controleer of er al een rapport is over hetzelfde onderwerp

Zo ja, gelieve dan voor dit rapport te STEMMEN. Rapporten met de meeste stemmen krijgen VOORRANG!

#	Status	Votes	Game	Type	Title	Last update

Gedetailleerde beschrijving

Rapportgeschiedenis

4 Mar 2024 18:02 • Léonidas Ier • De ontwikkelaars hebben deze suggestie nog niet geanalyseerd:

4 Mar 2024 18:10 • Kayvon • De ontwikkelaars denken dat dit geen goed idee is of dat de kosten/batenratio te hoog is:

The game already enforces delivery before city actions. If you wish to skip delivery, you can do a city action straight away. If you do want to deliver, you must do that first.

On top of all this, we've included a robust undo system. If you really meant to deliver first, you can undo back to that point. No need for an additional layer of confirmation.

4 Mar 2024 18:11 • Kayvon • De ontwikkelaars denken dat dit geen goed idee is of dat de kosten/batenratio te hoog is:

Report short description
"delivery And city action"
changed to
"Add additional confirmation before delivering"

21 May 2024 18:39 • Tomoaki Tokunaga • De ontwikkelaars denken dat dit geen goed idee is of dat de kosten/batenratio te hoog is:

Personally, I believe this confirmation message is necessary.

I consider myself to be a relatively cautious player of turn-based games, yet I still forgot to deliver once. Specifically, this happened during the first move of game #514151003, when I used a city action to discard my cards and gain 4 doubloons. This was the biggest and simplest mistake I've ever made.

Given the current specifications, I feel that mistakes like this will inevitably occur in situations where there are few actions to perform and I'm deliberating which disc to remove. This is because I progress without having time to go back.

A simple message would suffice, but could you display a confirmation message when a player performs city actions without delivering? Making a mistake early in the game makes the rest of it quite painful, and I think this confirmation message could significantly reduce such errors. What do you think?

Again, I feel this is necessary because there are situations where there are few actions to perform.

21 May 2024 18:49 • Mogri • De ontwikkelaars denken dat dit geen goed idee is of dat de kosten/batenratio te hoog is:

Notably, you can still undo when you have done what you describe. Only if you end your turn completely or somehow draw a card / start combat without delivering will you be locked in.

29 May 2024 17:01 • Tomoaki Tokunaga • De ontwikkelaars denken dat dit geen goed idee is of dat de kosten/batenratio te hoog is:

Yes, my point is that with the current system, there are situations where a single click of the end turn button after a mistake makes it impossible to undo, which is not ideal. My initial suggestion was to display a confirmation message particularly if there is only one step available, as having just one step significantly increases the likelihood of making mistakes. Maracaibo is a game with a lot of information to consider, and this doesn't help.

Of course, I think your program has many wonderful aspects, and this feedback is not meant to negate that. If it's difficult to make improvements from a cost-effectiveness standpoint, we will need to be even more careful to avoid mistakes while playing.

29 May 2024 17:10 • Kayvon • De ontwikkelaars denken dat dit geen goed idee is of dat de kosten/batenratio te hoog is:

We need to balance the ease of play with the confirmations.

> there are situations where a single click of the end turn button after a mistake makes it impossible to undo

In our view, that end turn button IS the confirmation. There's a robust undo system to allow you to undo any mistake. We've replaced the automated end-of-turn with the confirmation "End Turn" button, so the player has a chance to take one last look at the results of his decisions before confirming and ending his turn.

Once you've confirmed that and a new player's turn has started, it's too late to undo, of course. But adding a second "End Turn" confirmation seems redundant (and risks people asking why there isn't a third, etc.).

Dit rapport aanvullen

Gelieve hier alle informatie toe te voegen die relevant is om deze bug te reproduceren of jouw suggestie te begrijpen:

Andere tafel ID / zet ID
Loste F5 het probleem op?
Kwam het probleem meerdere keren voor? Altijd? Willekeurig?
Als je een screenshot van deze bug hebt (aan te raden), kun je een afbeeldingshostingsdienst naar keuze gebruiken (bijvoorbeeld snipboard.io) om deze te uploaden en hier de link te plakken.

Annuleer Werk rapport bij

#116449: "Add additional confirmation before delivering"

Waarover gaat dit rapport?

Wat is er gebeurd? Selecteer uit het onderstaande

Wat is er gebeurd? Selecteer uit het onderstaande

Controleer of er al een rapport is over hetzelfde onderwerp

Gedetailleerde beschrijving

Rapportgeschiedenis

Dit rapport aanvullen

Wijzig rapportstatus naar:

Help

Draag bij

Navigeren

Volg ons